Review: Cursive - Mama, I'm Swollen

I was not looking forward to when this album came up in my list of things to review. Not reviewing it was not an option: Cursive is one of my favorite bands of all time. Actually, that's what made it so hard. I keep holding out hope that I just don't understand this album, that one day I'll play it and just realize the genius that I just know Tim Kasher packed it full of. Unfortunately, that day hasn't come yet and so with a heavy heart I have to admit, I think this is probably the weakest Cursive offering to date.

That said, this isn't a terrible album. Almost any of the songs on it would be fine down-tempo numbers on a different Cursive album surround by bigger, screamier, more dynamic songs. They wouldn't be our favorites and when we talked about the album and someone mentioned them we'd be like "oh yeah, that song's on there too," but they wouldn't be bad. The problem with Mama, I'm Swollen (I hadn't actually gotten around to saying that yet had I?), is that it's a whole album of what I would hesitate to call 'filler tracks' but that's really the only word for them. When I talk to other people about Cursive we usually agree that as Tim Kasher cleaned his life up, the songs took a hit. Where the hard drinking, self-loathing Tim cranked out the truly awesome Domestica and The Ugly Organ, it was a much better situated Tim that gave us Happy Hollow and I would hazard a downright stable guy who wrote Mama. He can't even get it up to rage about religion anymore. Sure the album takes a few swings here and there ('We're Going to Hell' and 'Mama, I'm Satan') but they lack the teeth and claws of even an interlude from back in the old days.

The album opens with a rocker (it's only rocker, really) "In The Now" and then promptly hits its high points in "From the Hips" and "I Couldn't Love You." The latter is probably the closest this album gets to form with Kasher screwing up his face to scream "I couldn't love you anymooooooooore" (if you don't believe me just watch the video). After these three, the album just kind of coasts for seven tracks. Again, these are all fine songs. They're Cursive songs, they just aren't the best we've seen. And you know what? That's fine. Tim, if you're out there, you been through some stuff and it seems like you're coming out of it now and if that means you have to take your foot off the gas pedal a little bit then go for it, you've earned it. You don't have to prove anything anymore. This album is fine, I'll just mix in 'The Great Decay' 'The Recluse' and 'Tall tales' when I need a jolt. But for those of you who have never listened to Cursive, please don't make this the first album you listen to.

And now, the videos for the album (there were three. anyone else think that's a little excessive?)







Cursive - In The Now
Cursive - I Couldn't Love You

Financial Support Goes Here

Cursive